11/06/2026
What is the Socialist Case for Proportional Representation?
The Sandy Martin Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform interview
Andy Burnham has got us all talking about Proportional Representation (PR), and so we should be if we want to stop Nigel Farage marching into Downing Street with his own ‘wide but shallow parliamentary majority’. Bryn Griffiths of the Labour left Podcast spoke to Sandy Martin, the Chair of the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform, to consider what we need to do to get PR done.
You can watch the podcast on YouTube, Apple Podcasts Audible , Substack and listen to it on Spotify. You can even ask Alexa to play the Labour Left Podcast. Wherever you look just search for the Labour Left Podcast and it should be there. If you appreciate what we are doing, please give us a like and a follow. Every comment draws the podcast to a wider potential audience. Please, please, please share it with your friends as it gets the podcast to a wider audience.
The podcast traces a path which stretches right back to the Chartists, a working class and social reform movement of the 19th Century. Looking at our modern history, we discover the PR campaign is one of stops and false starts. We consider the 1980s campaign Charter 88; the 1997 Jenkins Commission; and, the forgotten Alternative Vote Referendum of 2011 under the Cameron-Clegg austerity government.
The Labour left has not always embraced PR, so Bryn shares his experience of joining the late Bob Cryer MP’s First Past the Post Campaign. Having explained Bob Cryer’s reasoning, he invites Sandy to rescue PR from Labour’s centrists and put today’s case for reform. Bryn also sets out his case that, if the facts change, you review your strategy.
Former Leader Neil Kinnock, a recent convert to PR, used to loathe the idea and Bryn cites his abusive riposte to the campaigners of an earlier generation.
In the second-half Bryn and Sandy start off by agreeing that the Makerfield by-election and the possible election of Andy Burnham could be the big moment for PR. With that in mind, Sandy tells us exactly what we need to do if we are going to get PR done, overturn Starmer and implement the historic 2022 Labour Conference policy shift.
Bryn Griffiths is an activist in Colchester Labour Party and North Essex World Transformed. He is the Vice-Chair of Momentum and sits on the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy’s Executive.